Comment from Sange
Congrats on this win Shawn Girl! Wow! Love the moon, the glow, and the superb framing of the silhouette branches with tiny heart shaped leaves.
Beautiful work! Well deserved win!
Bravo!

 Comment Written 09-Feb-2014

---

reply by the author on 10-Feb-2014

You didn't have to do this, Sange, but I thank you dearly! And thank you for the congrats and the wow!! Not many even knew I posted it, lol. :)

Comment from Lorraine E Knight
1. Title: Moonlit
2. Contest Entry: Lights and Shadows Art (b) contest rules traditional no photographs
3. Artist Notes: included technical and informative
4. Correct Category: Yes
5. Tone/Color: complementing
6. Type: Digital Painting
7. Perceptional Plane: Three dimensional qualities achieved.
8. Light/Shadows: Light source moon. Shadows darkest darks achieved
9. Proportions: Realistic
10. Technical Skill: expert to professional
11. Story or Article ready: Yes
12. Personal Comments: best of luck in contest, personal comments are reserved as this work is a contest entry

Thank you for sharing.

My personal perspective and comments should not ever be confused with a negative, critical, or bad critique. I apologize, if my review offends. My goal is not to harm, but to simply share my truth, which of course may not be your truth. My opinion and perspective are free to accept or reject. My only hope is that this has helped you in some way.

Lorraine

 Comment Written 24-Jan-2014

---

reply by the author on 25-Jan-2014

Lorraine, thank you ever so much!! :)MW

reply by Lorraine E Knight on 26-Jan-2014

:) you are welcome. Lorraine

Comment from BryanOldfield
Very atmospheric and dramatic. Really like the moon, both its self and the shadows/ highlights its creating.
Nice misty touch in the background trees

 Comment Written 22-Jan-2014

---

reply by the author on 22-Jan-2014

Bryan, thank you ever so much! :)

reply by BryanOldfield on 22-Jan-2014

My pleasure

Comment from Jairos
Dramatic Lighting Effect, Good Detail I like the presentation, good initial impact, beautiful Soft Colors, Well done , - jairos

 Comment Written 20-Jan-2014

---

reply by the author on 20-Jan-2014

Jairos, thank you ever so much. :)

Comment from Dick Lee Shia
Lights & silhouettes.
Impressive creation.
Dramatic framing by the bare twigs showcasing a pine forested area as illuminated by the full moon.
Cinematic lighting.
Imaginative idea.
Innovative presentation.
Creative approach.
Thanks for sharing...

 Comment Written 20-Jan-2014

---

reply by the author on 20-Jan-2014

Dick Lee, thank you so very very much. :)