Reviews from

Splash

Sunrise on Mexico's Caribbean Coast

33 total reviews 
Comment from SRM


Very nice sunrise photograph with gret colors and a nice surprise splash.

Initial Impact - 5
Creativity or uniqueness - 5
Technical Skill - 5
Focus - 5
Depth of Field - 5
Composition - 5
Lighting - 5

 Comment Written 29-Sep-2008


reply by the author on 29-Sep-2008
    Thank you so much for you very generous review.
Comment from mackpwo


I agree with you. They are never exactly like the one before it, or after it. There is always something uniquely beautiful. I love the SPLASH you captured. That is a nice touch, and great timing!

 Comment Written 29-Sep-2008


reply by the author on 29-Sep-2008
    Thank you so much for viewing and your kind comments.
Comment from lorac1


What I find unique about this picture is the wave breaking over the rock in the foreground. It has a strong initial impact, and a center of interest that keeps one looking.

My only suggestion for improvement is to crop a bit at the top of the photo to give better balance.

 Comment Written 29-Sep-2008


reply by the author on 29-Sep-2008
    Thank you for you generous review and your helpful suggestions. I cropped the picture but it never occurred to me to crop of the top because I liked the blue above the clouds but I will certainly take your suggestion in consideration.
Comment from bonitAjadehya


For me, the attraction is the splash of the wave. you can capture it will well. The sunset as the background has a beautiful color. Is it real or retouch? The cloud a bit messy, but thats's ok. After all this is a good pic. Keep up. ^^

 Comment Written 29-Sep-2008


reply by the author on 29-Sep-2008
    Thank you for your generous review. No there is no retouch. Its all real including the messy cloud I didn't want to correct nature. I hope you don't mine a little correction: It's an sunrise.
reply by bonitAjadehya on 29-Sep-2008
    hahaha...my bad...sorry...
    so I will correct it now.
    It's a sunrise, everyone!!! ^^
reply by the author on 29-Sep-2008
    Sorry, that I even mentioned that. Most people think is a sunset. I think sunrise and sunsets have so much the same colors that the difference is hard to tell. Surprisingly for me most reviewers think it is a sunset. You were just the first one were I read it. It's probaly because most people are more used to see the sun rising over land and sinking into the ocean.
Comment from ARTHOUND


you right each sun set is like a ever changing canvas a constant picture in action changing all the time and allway's different this is a a wesonme shot i like the water you caught splashing up to the sky good catchdrop's are really high the sky is beautifull great field of depth and presentation arthound

 Comment Written 29-Sep-2008


reply by the author on 29-Sep-2008
    Thank you so much Arthound for your generous review and your beautiful words about the ever changing sky.
Comment from wingsoflove


You know what I like about this sunrise dear heart? The splashes of water that came with it. Truly Gods creation in form and everyday its totally different and a mystery but a wonderful mystery. Thank you for sharing your magnificent photos.

 Comment Written 29-Sep-2008


reply by the author on 29-Sep-2008
    Thank you wingsoflove for your warm hearted and generous review.
Comment from Photophile


Hello Cleo,
You do love your sunsets don't you. I assume that is because you are good at it. Again you have well controlled sun with minimal burned highlight and no banding frequently seen in sunsets which come close to burned highlights. Indeed, you sky is excellent. You have come low with your camera and tried to capture waves, which is another good thing.

There are two reasons why I deducted a point from your score. First, you need to "fill light" in software to bring up some details in your water. However when you do that, you are likely to find out that your water is not "frozen" and the details will be soft. I would go with shutterspeeds of no less than 1/500 sec and preferable 1/1000 sec to freeze water. The alternative is long exposures (of about 1/4 sec) to get a nice silky effect. Your shutterspeed is in between.

The result of all that is that you foreground reduces, rather than enhances the effect of sunset. I hope that this helps. Pavel

This rating does not count towards story rating or author rank.
The highest and the lowest rating are not included in calculations.

 Comment Written 29-Sep-2008


reply by the author on 29-Sep-2008
    Thanks Pavel, as always a great and helpful review. I tryed to fill light in software but it is exact what you assumed. The water doesn't look to good.
    I'll try your suggestions. I'm afraid the long exposure will be inpossible. I can't use a tripod in this situation. It is just inpossible to mount one on our beach. For this photo I was on my belly head down on the steep angled rocky beach camera hand hold near the water. I'm just not stable enough for long exposure. But the shutter speed should work.
    Heidi
reply by Photophile on 29-Sep-2008
    Good. I am glad you find my review useful. Tha fact is that to some extent photography is the art of possible ... You can not always do the best thing and you just try to do what you can. Best of luck Heidi. Pavel
reply by the author on 29-Sep-2008
    Thanks for your kind reply and the good wishes. -Heidi
Comment from Snopaw


There is no usch thing as too many sunrises and sunsets, that would be like too many flowers, lol. This is really a lovely shot, and I vole the splash of water, an nice break in the action. You do very well with your Point and Shoot camera I must say. Shirley

 Comment Written 29-Sep-2008


reply by the author on 29-Sep-2008
    Thanks you so much Shirley for your generous review.
    But may I correct. My cameras aren't point and shoot. For this picture I used my Sony DSC-H9 what is a good middle class camera [I think about $ 500,- in the US]. What means all flaws in my photos now and in future is my fals never the camera as in point and shoot.
reply by Snopaw on 29-Sep-2008
    Hi Cleo, I didn't mean to insult your camera but I guess I refer to any camera that is not a DSLR as a point and shoot. Acutally the DSLR are often used as a point and shoot because you can set them into the different modes and let the camera do the work. I have seen some very good photogrphy with the Cybershot cameras, but the type of photography such as you see done by Smokie and Ranbo require the ability to change the lens and manually all of your settings. Shirley
reply by the author on 29-Sep-2008
    Thanks for your Re. Actually I can change lenses on this camera and set the settings manually. Truth I have often some of the automatic settings.
    I dislike to talk about but I think I have to explain: The digital age saved me from giving up photography. I can't use my old film cameras anymore. My eyes are to bad for the view finder. I need that big LCD but even there I have often trouble to read the menu. That' when I use automatic. Most of the time these bad eyes are a blessing since my tunnel vision let me see as a camera dos. I see a picture in my mine before it is taken and without looking though a view finder.
    Please ignore what I just said about my eyes when reviewing my photos.
    -Heidi
Comment from ega39


I am crazy about sunrises and sunsets and can tell you that they are all different
I love the colors,they are yummy
contrast is great
and I love the way you capture the splash
Great shot
Thanks for sharing
I enjoyed very much

 Comment Written 29-Sep-2008


reply by the author on 29-Sep-2008
    Thank you so much ega39 for your generous review and your kind comments.
Comment from happyartist4 /!!!/


Very beautiful picture! I love the lovely sunset in the background with the ocean water splashing about in the air. I can appreciate that beauty very much because I live in Colorado where there are no beaches. The only thing I wished with this photo is that there was a little more clarity. Thank you for sharing :)

 Comment Written 29-Sep-2008


reply by the author on 29-Sep-2008
    Thank you for your generous review. The clarity is a bit of a problem. It was hazy over the water [100% humidity]. The shutter speed wasn't ideal for the wave below but it wasn't set for it.I actually didn't suspected the water coming that height. The splash was a gift.
reply by happyartist4 /!!!/ on 30-Sep-2008
    Awwww, thant is really great! Yeah, I live in Colorado, I wouldn't understand what it is like to take a picture in 100% humidity :) Thank you for explaining :)
reply by the author on 30-Sep-2008
    Thanks :)