Comment from avmurray
It is an amazing shot. For obvious reasons I can't comment on colors or light, but I can say that what we see of the moon is very sharp showing the surface real well. I like the cropping leaving space around the moon, and I also like the placement within the frame. You have done well, and I wish you good luck with the contest.

 Comment Written 30-May-2011

---

reply by the author on 30-May-2011

Thank you, I truly appreciate your review and wishes.

Comment from kitchnwitch
This photo actually saddens me. Not because its a bad photo but because of the thought that it instills in me. I lost my mom 2 years ago and I still find myself looking to the heavens, the moon the stars. Looking for a sign that she is watching over me. That falling star that might be by chance or was it a sign from above. Its a beautiful photo.

 Comment Written 30-May-2011

---

reply by the author on 30-May-2011

Thank you, I appreciate your review very much but I am saddened by the tought of your sadness. Maybe that you saw the beauty of the moon in this picture is the sign you wait for.

reply by kitchnwitch on 30-May-2011

the moon is beautiful I agree. its a lovely picture.

Comment from joelise
Good initial impact. Excellent focus and lighting. B&W is a very good choice to displaying the Gibbous Moon. The very clear image of the moon surface is the center of interest. Good composition, cropping and framing. Good technique, technical skill and story telling potential. Creativity in title, presentation and artist's notes.

 Comment Written 30-May-2011

---

reply by the author on 30-May-2011

Thank you very much, your review is truly appreciated.

reply by joelise on 30-May-2011

You are very welcome, joelise

Comment from DiannaM
Very nice job. Love the contrasts and you've got awesome detail and tone in the moon. Not easy to achieve!

 Comment Written 30-May-2011

---

reply by the author on 30-May-2011

Thank you, I appreciate your review very much.