Reviews from

what a strange dry leaf

Kalima inachus

18 total reviews 
Comment from helvi2


Hi Super,
This is the most amazing butterfly I have ever seen! With the wings open it's beautiful and one would never expect with wings closed it was a butterfly. I voted for you in the contest and was happy to see you'd won. It this isn't camouflage I don't know what is?

I saw your note in the forum and couldn't believe people didn't take the time to look this up! I did! I knew it was some kind of insect and was rewarded by seeing it was a beautiful butterfly.GREAT JOB! :o) Helvi

 Comment Written 24-Mar-2017


reply by the author on 24-Mar-2017
    thanks a lot Helvi for your lovely comments;
    unfortunately it is not the first time that people write stupid comments without reading the notes or subtitle:;
reply by helvi2 on 24-Mar-2017
    There have been times when the same thing has happened to me so I know how you feel. It can be frustrating when you have to keep explaining and you've already included information when you posted your image! One of the things I love about FAR is the discovery of seeing something new and taking a closer look! :o)
Comment from Theo van Stratum


Ok, fallen from another tree? wind? LOL many possibilities

As an photo, maybe not that interesting, but the exposure and composition are good

Thanks for sharing

 Comment Written 21-Mar-2017


reply by the author on 21-Mar-2017
    do you really think I posted a dry leaf for my camouflage contest ??
reply by Theo van Stratum on 21-Mar-2017
    no but you asked the question :-0
reply by the author on 21-Mar-2017
    did you see the name "Kalima inachus" that I put at the top?
    please have a look on Google.....
Comment from jesuel


What a great photo the color is great the detail is great e cellent depth and I like how you have captured the only brown leaf great capture here

 Comment Written 09-Mar-2017


reply by the author on 09-Mar-2017
    this is not a leaf!
Comment from SteveANH


The magic leave! LOL I wonder if it's connected to the slender light green leaf.

You have great command of the depth of field with perfectly faded background!

Excellent work!

Wow was I fooled! With a closer look I can make out the little legs! (red faced!)

 Comment Written 09-Mar-2017


reply by the author on 09-Mar-2017
    it is a butterfly;
    many thanks again
Comment from EvaB


Well shot with good focus on the dry leaf. Well exposed. I wondered if possible some type of insect that mimics a leaf? Interesting shot.

 Comment Written 08-Mar-2017


reply by the author on 08-Mar-2017
    many thanks eva; I indicated the name: kalima inachus: it is a butterfly!
Comment from Gail Ross


It does have the same vein down the middle as the other. I'm thinking when the green leaves die and dry up their shape changes because of lost moisture? Nice focus and very interesting composition.

 Comment Written 08-Mar-2017


reply by the author on 08-Mar-2017
    many thanks gail;
    I indicated the name; kalima inachus; it is a butterfly!
reply by Gail Ross on 09-Mar-2017
    Amazing! Great camouflage.
Comment from PeglegDeb


Well good eye on your part....oops...lol...almost used your name there. Good eye....bet most people would have not even given this a second glance....if they even noticed it in the first place.

Excellent focus on your little outlier. Well detailed enough to allow for comparison w/ the other leaves. Good color and perfect exposure. Your little square format is just right for the more oval shape of the leaves and your very unusual butterfly.

As to what it's doing there. hmmnn lol...well I read all the notes and I can see his legs. Wonderful capture sg! Your posts are some of the most educational ones here. Best of luck w/ your photo here. Has to be the very best camouflage for sure.

Deborah

 Comment Written 08-Mar-2017


reply by the author on 08-Mar-2017
    thanks a lot deborah for your lovely comments
reply by PeglegDeb on 08-Mar-2017
    Loved this one! Bet it does well in the contest.
Comment from eileen0204


Wow, certainly does look like a leaf Fred! How amazing nature is!

I can just see the legs and head of this butterfly. Nicely camouflaged indeed!!

Nicely detailed as well. Well done.

 Comment Written 08-Mar-2017


reply by the author on 08-Mar-2017
    thanks a lot Eileen for your nice comments
reply by eileen0204 on 08-Mar-2017
    such a pleasure fred
Comment from Sange


This is for sure camaflouge at its best! This is in the butterfly family.
Kallima inachus is a nymphalid butterfly found in tropical Asia from India to Japan. When it has its wings closed, it closely resembles a dry leaf with dark veins. What a Great example of camouflage.
Where did you find this?
You have nice focus but I would clone out the distracting white spots and maybe even crop tighter.
I can't speak for people's Opinions here ... I have a few hung up on my horse shot. Nobody reads. You gave away what this was in your description above the title.
Great entry for the contest.

 Comment Written 08-Mar-2017


reply by the author on 08-Mar-2017
    thanks a lot Sandra for your great comments;
    despite giving the name and writing Something "mysterious, I got three 4 from people claiming that a dry leaf isn't appropriate for the contest! crazy people on this site: they never read all détails;
reply by Sange on 08-Mar-2017
    No...And when you suggest they look it up and research it.....They get BENT. WHATEVS...
    It's an insect.. not a leaf...
    Been here long enough to know that changes on the site take place.... But with the people? Not so much.
    :)
Comment from michiganmike


If it is anything other than a dead leaf that has fallen into this cluster, it sure has me fooled. I have seen insects that mimic leaves, but this does not seem to be one. Great colors and nice detail throughout.

 Comment Written 07-Mar-2017


reply by the author on 07-Mar-2017
    look again mike; there are legs; and I put the b=name at the top: kalima inachus.......
    it is worth to Google.....
    thanks again