Reviews from

Memory Of Rose

commission work

14 total reviews 
Comment from Kevin Klier


Nice. What did the commission require or what was asked? My first reaction was this guy is in prison and is thinking of his girl. I am probably way off!

 Comment Written 23-Oct-2022


reply by the author on 24-Oct-2022
    The clients dad dies some time ago. He was a big fan of the Willie Nelson song "Gypsies Rose". After looking thru her collection of photos I found the perfect expression of him. I'm a cartoonist and normally don't pursue doing portraits. However when I do I want to know more about the person that I illustrate. You know tell a brief story that represents them. I did chuckle over the prison comment. The family was aware of the story but I can see that the cartoon can represent many possible stories.
    Like I said before. I don't pursue portraits. Only so much time to do cartoons create videos and keep up with many websites. Thanks for the great review.
Comment from seshadri_sreenivasan


Your concept for creating a new kind of artwork and innovation is visible here. I'm sure your client was delighted. Keep it up. What more can I say!

 Comment Written 22-Oct-2022


reply by the author on 26-Oct-2022
    Thanks Bro for the awesome review
Comment from helvi2


Hi Mark, I had to look at the reviews you got to figure out what this was about. First of all I think you did an outstanding job on the man you drew! I don't even know how you can be so precise with sharpies. The coloring and shading is perfection.
By reading what you replied to one of the reviewers I see this from the daughter's viewpoint. Since the daughter is picturing her father, I see this as her imagining her father listening to "Gypsy Rose" because it was a song he loved. It's what she sees in her mind's eye. I like the way you did the vision of Gypsy in a lighter dreamlike mode. I like the spot light on your client's dad. I could be off with my thoughts, but the drawing is impressive and the daughter loves it! I know that had to make you happy! Nice to see your work again! :o) Nancy

 Comment Written 09-Oct-2022


reply by the author on 10-Oct-2022
    It's a normal reaction when folks find out that someone can draw they want a portrait of something. Really any artist can do that. However since Im a cartoonist my approach is illustrating what is the highlight of this person that others can recognize and understand the cartoon. Glad ya like it a thanks for awesome review. Still working on the rock video
reply by helvi2 on 11-Oct-2022
    Hi Mark, I know what a BIG project the "Rock video" is! LOL I have the feeling it's the biggest project you've ever done! I know it was for me. I think it needs the time you're taking to put all the pieces together. Whenever you finish is fine with me. I know in the end your special touches will make the project sing!! :o) Nancy
Comment from koponenj


Interesting piece. I can tell you've spent a lot of time on this. The effort you put into it speaks for itself. I like how it's broken up into two pieces. I also like how you used light and dark.

This rating does not count towards story rating or author rank.
The highest and the lowest rating are not included in calculations.

 Comment Written 08-Oct-2022


reply by the author on 10-Oct-2022
    1st of all welcome to FAR. May all of your adventures are successful. If you have any questions please feel free to contact me. I will reply. Now onto the reply. It is a nice review that you have given and I thank you for your time of doing that. The 4 1/2 star rating represents that you think it is good but need improvement. I disagree but thanks for your time of reviewing it.
Comment from avmurray


You have not told us very much about this image, but the portrait of this guy is really well done, and since the customer is satisfied, she must agree. I especially like the expression in the face and how lovely the light is falling on it.

I also like the all black background, the limited color pallet and the beam of light behind the man. I have a feeling that the drawing of the woman has something to do with the Rose.

The format and framing is just perfect, and it is such a fine flow and balance in the composition. A truly great looking and well done portrait Mark.

 Comment Written 08-Oct-2022


reply by the author on 11-Oct-2022
    Hey AV..yeah I know I didn't put much notes out there with this. The gentleman in the drawing is dead. He was a big fan of the Willie Nelson song "Gypsy Rose". His daughter commissioned me to create something in his memory. After talking to her about him this is what I came up with. She loved it. Thanks for the awesome review
reply by avmurray on 14-Oct-2022
    You are more than welcome Mark, and thanks for the information.
Comment from jesuel


what a great piece of art the color composition is great the design is both creative and unique the portrait looks great as well as your flesh tones fine work here

 Comment Written 06-Oct-2022


reply by the author on 11-Oct-2022
    Thanks #1 for the awesome review
Comment from Mr Jones


this is so very good. really love the expression on the face and the details you have packed into the composition. the colours are very natural and the shading is also a very strong feature.

 Comment Written 06-Oct-2022


reply by the author on 11-Oct-2022
    They we talking about you the other day in the forum. Carina has left us and others were wondering if you did too. It shows your fans were concerned about you. Thought you would like to know. I really haven't been active here since June. Anyone notice? Nahhh.. lol...thanks bro for your time and the great review.
Comment from alaskapat


Hi Mark, it's good to see you posting again!
This is a very well created piece, I can see that this man has lost Rose , she must have really meant a lot to him, he is well created, nice face shape, good show of the facial structure, well applied facial features, his expression is sadness as he remembers Rose, I like the way you created her off to the left, as if she has just materialized there.
Well presented!

 Comment Written 06-Oct-2022


reply by the author on 06-Oct-2022
    I know I didn't detailed the artist notes. The gentleman in this drawing is dead. He was a big fan of Willie Nelson's song Gypsy Rose. His daughter commissioned me to do something of her dad. After asking more questions about the guy I got an idea what to create this for her. She loved it..wink
    Thanks for the great review
Comment from CorbyLinda


The man here is done so well. His memory is sweet.

Sharpies work well for this portrait. I've never tried them. I might just now.

Great job and you client must be very happy.

 Comment Written 05-Oct-2022


reply by the author on 06-Oct-2022
    I do get tickled when a reviewer says "nice painting". Of course I have inform them that it's not a painting but a drawing instead. Also I don't work with any art medium. Mine is a office medium. Been work with sharpie and bic pens for over a half century now. Try em out. You might like em. Wink. Thanks for the great review
reply by CorbyLinda on 06-Oct-2022
    Lol. I love the sharpie usage. I have yo give it a try. Thank you and you are very welcome
Comment from Way West


This is a pretty work! I like the softness of the presentation which provides great ambiance. The man is realistic and his eyes seem alive, watching. Well done, thanks for sharing!

 Comment Written 05-Oct-2022


reply by the author on 11-Oct-2022
    Thanks for the great review